Skip to content

More about Fractional Series

Vector 11:2, page 30

mathematics and statistics education

Transcribed from the printed issue; not yet reviewed. Read it in the PDF of the issue, page 30

In Jot-Dot-Floor (Education Vector 11.1, pp. 31–35) the author refers to the series:

\[\begin{equation*} \sum_{n=0}^{N-1} X^n = \bigl(X^n - 1\bigr)\big/(X-1) \tag*{1} \end{equation*}\]

and asks why it doesn’t work for fractional N. Start with the case X=1:

\[\begin{equation*} \textstyle\sum 1^n = 0/0 \end{equation*}\]

but the RHS can be evaluated by taking the limit X=1+delta as delta approaches zero. So

\[\begin{equation*} 1 + 1 + 1 + \ldots = N \end{equation*}\]

which is just the count of the terms in the sum. It looks reasonable that a fractional number of terms will count to the fraction. (Much as N=0 counts the empty series.)

In the general case the RHS of equation 1 can be evaluated just as easily for fractional (or irrational or transcendental) N as for integers so, whatever the fractional series means, we can define its sum as whatever the RHS evaluates to. For example with X=4 and N=2.5 the sum is 31/3. Staying with X=4 and various N we have:

N Sum N Sum
1 1 1.5 2.333..
2 5 2.5 10.333..
3 21 3.5 42.333..
4 85 4.5 170.333..

Negative values of N are not a problem. For N=−1

\[\begin{equation*} \bigl(X^{-1} - 1\bigr)\big/(X-1) \end{equation*}\]

evaluates to −1/X and for the general case of negative integer N to

\[\begin{equation*} -\frac{1}{X} - \frac{1}{X^2} - \frac{1}{X^3} \ldots \end{equation*}\]

This can be understood as follows. To go from N=2 to N=1 take away the term with n=1. To go from N=0 to N=−1 take away the term with n=−1. Fractional negative N just combines this concept for negative N with that for fractional N.

The graph shows the sum for X=2 and a continuous range of N from −3 to 2.6 as an example. The shape of the curve is, of course, exponential.

      )load rain
      xx← ¯3+0.1×0,⍳56

chset ('style' 'boxed,xyplot,nomark,grid')
chset ('yint' 0)('xint' 0)('xcap' 'N')('ycap' 'Sum for X=2')
chset ('nib' 'medium')
chplot  xx,[1.5] ¯1+2*xx
View chclose

Graph of Sum for X=2 against N from −3 to 3: a curve rising from about −0.9 at N=−3 through 0 at N=0 to about 5 at N=2.6

Dr J R Sutton